Contributor Guidelines
We value contributions from academics, practitioners and policy-makers. Scholarly-based and reflective practitioner of human resource development have a unique opportunity to both make use of the research published in The International Journal of Human Resource Development Practice, Policy & Research as well as contribute their knowledge and perspectives from practice to inform ongoing research in the field. Practitioners of human resource development (HRD) are on the front lines of utilizing promising practices derived from research implications as often as they are grappling with emerging challenges impacting an increasingly technologically and globally diverse population. It is this position as practitioners who are engaged with the literature on human resource development that excites us. With a variety of paper types being introduced by the new journal co-editors, we hope practitioners will bring their experiences to bear in articles aimed for an audience interested considering how practice informs research and research informs practice in human resource development.
We welcome contributions that not only informs our readers of ‘what is new’ but also in a manner that is cogent. Differentiating the types of papers guides contributors to develop more rigorous and focused articles, within a word count range that maintains the attention and interest of readers. Of course we recognise that, for example, an article can begin with an evaluation of the implementation of a new training programme, which then goes on to conceptualise a new approach based on lessons learned. Nonetheless, a high quality article that reports an evaluation of a programme will entail a description of the aims of programme, methodology, results and its comparison with the programme aims, and recommendations. Such level of detail in itself merits the focus on an entire paper.
We now adopt a ‘your paper, your way’ approach. What this approach entails is that you can adopt any style in your submission to the journal (Harvard, Chicago etc). However, upon acceptance of your paper, you will need to reformatted, if not already, to the journal’s style; American Psychological Association (APA) 6th Edition. Authors must specify the type of paper that they are submitting.
Conceptual paper
Conceptual papers should present an idea, concept, or framework through the use of literature support to address a practice-oriented problem offering potential solutions or critique. These papers can provide a ‘new way of seeing’ and/ or gives us a glimpse into the near future. It may seek to identify new information on a topic, build on existing theory, or provide an opportunity to build an argument for further research a subject. Conceptual papers may culminate in diagrams that summarises all the elements and its relationship with one another in a succinct manner.
Submission guidelines. Word count between 4,000 – 5,000 words excluding references. Usually does not include empirical data but draws upon influential literature.
Critical reflection
In critical reflections, the ‘journey’ is more important than the ‘destination’. Such articles takes the reader through journey of the author’s sensemaking and sensegiving processes. They help the author to articulate the way they have made sense of complex problems and why they may have interpreted a phenomenon in a particular manner. These reflections are critical because they explore the paradox, tension, perceived impasse and other issues that the author has experienced. Critical reflection/ auto-ethnobiography do not just draw on the cognitive (rational) aspects of the journey but also on emotional and relational (e.g. lived) experiences. The value that readers can draw from critical reflection is not just the ‘conclusions’ drawn by the author but also in the richness of the story itself.
Submission guidelines. Word count between 3,000 – 4,000 words excluding references. Likely to include a description of the author circumstances (e.g. role in organisation) as this provides a sense of why the object and/ or subject of reflection is important to the author.
Evaluation
An evaluation paper of a model, strategy, program, or other impact to practice provides readers insight into the efficacy found in your organisation and could drive further research on the subject. Writing an evaluation paper with research colleagues may give you the opportunity to gain insight into making changes or developing alternative practices based on what is learned.
Submission guidelines. Word count between 5,000 – 7,000 words excluding references. Draws upon data and provides a clear sense of the methodology in collecting and analysing the data.
Literature Reviews
Articles in this category systematically review and integrate academic literature. These papers critically evaluate the state of knowledge in HRD and its adjacent fields. In identifying and offering strategic platform for new directions in research, these articles provide new models and/ or frameworks that advancing current and future research.
Submission guidelines. Word count between 6,000 – 8,000 words excluding references.
Provocation
Provocation have many purposes. Nevertheless, a frequent purpose of provocations to helps others to ‘see’ an existing phenomenon in different ways and to conjecture ‘what ifs’. If provocation itself is not novel, the reasons for it can be. To give you an idea, a provocation may involve highlighting that there are opportunities in a trend that is typically viewed as problematic. Similarly a provocation is adopting an ‘integrated’ (converging) view that shows how two seemingly unrelated phenomena may be symbiotic. We hope that provocation help to shape new trajectories of thinking and line enquiries in practice, policy and/ or research.
Submission guidelines. Word count between 3,000 – 5,000 words excluding references. Similar to a conceptual paper, a provocation article usually does not include empirical data but draws upon influential literature. Tends to highlight contradictions and anomalies.
Research Paper
Research papers are, as with the other papers, original and empirical-based research. We accept a quantitative and qualitative papers for research and scholarship on HRD-orientated themes and topics.
Submission guidelines. Word count between 5,000 – 7,000 words excluding references.
________________________________
By invitation only:
Books and resource reviews
In the interest of providing journal readers with information about new books and resources relevant to the study and practice of human resource development, book and resource reviews may be submitted by invitation from the editors.
Submission guidelines. Word count between 2,000 – 3,000 words excluding references.
Conversation
A conversation paper between esteemed practitioners, which may also involve a member of the editorial board. The practitioners are persons who have interest around a common topic is an effective way to convey shared or dissenting views on the subject and promote further knowledge for practice and research and may be submitted by invitation from the Editors.
Exemplary contribution
Exemplary contributions are by invitation from the journal to potential authors who may wish to share their stories of achievement, which are notable and may be of interest to many of our readers. Authors may be practitioners from private, public and voluntary sectors but also policy makers and scholars who are not just in the field of HRD but also parties interested in the advancement of HRD. These contributions may be to, but not limited to, economic, social and environmental causes. The exemplary contributions may take the form of the articles types discussed critical reflections.
Submission guidelines. Word count between 3,000 – 4,000 words excluding references. Likely to highlight evidence of achievements and attainments.
We appreciate that it is difficult to convey complex ideas and issues in a concise manner, and we do consider the contribution-to-length ratio of each article. Nonetheless, please bear in mind that readers and reviewers will lose interest if the paper is unnecessarily verbose. In expanding the types of papers to be published by the International Journal of Human Resource Development Practice, Policy & Research we hope to further encourage practitioners to contribute articles to help inform ongoing research and to collaborate with researchers to develop practice-based research. HRD is a field of practice with broad impacts across all organizations. As a domain of study, researchers are always seeking to further understand what is taking place within organizations, and it is through collaboration with and information from practitioners engaged in the work of HRD that much the best research comes about. The aim of this journal is to foster and support papers that make a broad impact to organisations spanning the globe where research informs practice of HRD and practice provides the foundation for research exploration.
Authors are welcome to discuss their ideas with either the co-Editor in Chief or any of the Associate Editors.